I always get asked what skillet / pan I like for cooking. Here are my criteria
- Never use a non-stick pan, basically cooking on poison and can't take high heat.
- Never use Aluminum, not good for you.
- Enameled pans are just tough to clean.
- Look for simple pans, so nothing that is some sorta high tech engineered surface that has been to the moon and back.
- Surface must be ultra smooth.
- Needs to be able to go from the cooktop to the oven to the grill.
- Needs to be easy to clean and withstand a good scrubbing.
- Don't use a pan that needs a special cooking utensil.
Here is my list starting with my favorite.
Cast Iron
Cast Iron pans are the ones I use the most. They are easy to clean, non-stick, durable and will last for many cooks lifetimes.
I have a number of pans (Wagner and Griswolds), a couple I inherited and others giving to me as a rusty mess. Some of these pans are more than 50 years old, you will never find or want to find a 50 year non-stick pan. I can easily cook an egg, omelet, fish, steak, etc with no stick and using a small amount of oil. They perform much much better than any non-stick, teflon pan or some high tech pan that was "engineered" for cooking.
Some manufacturers I like are
Smithey,
Field Company and
Merten & Storck. Older manufacturers, which I love, include Wagner and Griswold which are no longer made. Old pans are quality cast iron which are now being replicated by some of the newer Cast Iron manufacturers. Look in thrift stores, Etsy or eBay are great places to hunt for the older Griswolds and Wagners. Don't worry if the pan looks in rough shape. With a bit of cleaning and sanding the pans can be recovered and ready for use.
Lodge is another name you will hear. Lodge makes decent cast iron and found in many retailers. I don't prefer them because they are not polished smooth and have a rough texture which tends to create more sticking. I have a couple large Lodge pizza pans which I use for smash burgers on my grill. I have sanded these smooth to avoid sticking.
Carbon Steel
Carbon Steel is my second choice. I have a few carbon steel, one is my Wok.
Merten & Storck and
Smithey make nice pans. For a Wok, you can usually fine affordable ones at your local Asia grocery/cooking store. Carbon Steel pans are similar to Cast Iron, they are usually less expensive. Just like Cast Iron, keep the pan smooth, clean and always make sure the pan is hot before adding oil.
Stainless Steel
Stainless Steel is another good choice which avoid non-stick coating but not all pans can go into the oven and putting one on the grill will create a sooty mess. I have a couple pans but don't use them much. The main reason I don't use them is they take a bit more special care to keep clean and polished. Just like Cast and Carbon, make sure the pan is clean and the pan is hot before adding oil.
Cleaning Tips for Cast Iron and Carbon Steel
When anyone uses one of my cast iron or carbon steel pans, they hand it to me with "I know you have some special way to clean it so I don't want to ruin the seasoning". Well my "special" way does require some effort, doesn't use the dishwasher and I don't care about the seasoning. Here is what I do.
- Soap is not required but can be used.
- Never ever put the pan in the dishwasher. Dishwashers should only be used for ceramic and glass!!
- If pan has left over food, fill it with hot water and let it sit. Yup just water but wait "It will rust". Who cares and you aren't going to leave it for days, just a few hours
- Use a Chain Mail scrubber with a bit of elbow grease. Don't worry about the seasoning, scrub it to remove all materials and get the surface back to smooth. Any rough spots creates possible sticking areas. FYI.. chain mail scrubber is great for cleaning dirty hands; bit of soap and rub the scrubber between hands.
- Wipe clean with a paper towel to dry. You can use a cloth towel but the pan will always have some black residue which then gets on the towel.
- Toss on the stove on low temp to dry. Oh yeah, I have forgotten about pans on the stove for some hours and come back to a very hot pan which has had it's "seasoning" cooked out. Well, bit of oil and pan is ready to go.
- If you want, add a bit of oil and wipe with paper towel.
- If there are spots that aren't quite smooth to the touch, get some steel wool or 200 or higher grit sandpaper. Sand it until it is smooth.
Cleaning Tips for Stainless Steel
One concern with keeping a Stainless Steel pan clean is not to scratch the surface. Like Cast Iron and Carbon Steel you want to make sure the pan surface is clean and smooth. Here is what I do.
- Never put the pan in the dishwasher, not a good environment for any metal pan.
- Don't use an abrasive scrubber, so no chain mail scrubber.
- If leftover food in the pan, fill with hot water and let sit.
- Use a bristle brush.
- To remove leftover residue, coat the bottom of the pan with baking soda and dribble dish soap on the surface. Cover with a wet paper towel then let sit for hour or so. You will want a ratio of soda to water so you can make a paste. After rest time, use the paper towel or your fingers to rub the soda past around the pan to scrub off the residue.
Worries about seasoning
Cast Iron and Carbon Steel have a lot of information about seasoning. Seasoning helps protect the pan from rusty and can help with non-stick. I don't worry about having a "well seasoned" pan. Most important to me is that the surface is clean and smooth. Seasoning can buildup and cause stickiness. If you saw many of my pans, they look as if the seasoning has been scrubbed off, which it has. You can rub in a bit of oil to store them for preventing rust.
Heavy
If you prefer a lighter pan then go with Carbon Steel. Cast Iron is heavy, that is one of its best traits since it holds heat. There are some cast iron brands which are lighter; Griswold and
Field Company are a couple. A nice heavy pan cooks great and gives you time to build your arm strength. No other pot beats a cast iron dutch oven for roasting!
Have some rust spots
Rust is no issue. Scrub it off, if needed use a bit of steel wool. Dry the pan and hit it with a bit of oil.
PS. As for cooktops, Induction rules - faster, more control and no soot. I have cooked on gas which everyone thinks is tops but it is dirty and covers pans with soot. All other gas appliances in your house are required by law to have a vent stack, why not a gas cooktop/oven and when was the last time an induction/electric oven blew up. Since I have used induction my pans are much cleaner and no worries about leaking gas of carbon monoxide. Gas is an old wood stove compared to Induction!